Goodreads Review: Conspiracy by Means of Natural Selection

“Conspiracy by Means of Natural Selection” is a book written by Sherman P. Bastarache. This book asks a very big and interesting question: why do humans naturally believe in conspiracy theories? Instead of just talking about modern conspiracies and fake news, the author goes much deeper and looks at human evolution itself. The main objective of the book is to explain how conspiring behavior could have been naturally selected in human nature. What was the first reason that made humans start to conspire? The author argues that if we don’t understand how nature actually built our minds, we will never truly understand why we create theories that are perfectly moulded to fit what we already believe. To answer this, he looks at how ancient cultures, their gods, goddesses, and creation myths were all part of humanity’s early attempt to understand nature, gain knowledge, and ultimately get control over our world and other people.

A great aspect is how the book connects ancient history with modern problems. It is not just about evolution in a scientific way. It shows the link between ancient creation myths and today’s conspiracy theories and fake news. The author makes a convincing point that our search for control and meaning is the same now as it was thousands of years ago. The story it tells is not about one person, but about the whole human mind — how it evolved to see patterns, to form groups, and to protect its own beliefs. That perspective is fresh and makes a lot of sense.

Another positive aspect is how the author treats the different human groups in the book almost like characters in our evolutionary story, showing how each one has used belief systems and stories to make sense of the world. It makes you think about your own beliefs. The book talks about how this tendency to believe in conspiracies can be found in all kinds of people; rich and poor, religious and non-religious, scientists and non-scientists. It does not single out one group as the problem. Instead, it shows that this is a shared human trait. This balanced view makes the argument more believable and forces you to look inward instead of just blaming others.

What you can learn from this book is a lot about yourself. It teaches you to pause and question why you believe what you believe. It shows that we often shape information to fit our existing beliefs, rather than changing our beliefs to fit the truth. Reading it helps you become more aware of your own biases and more careful about accepting stories that simply sound good. It teaches critical thinking in a very practical way. There was no aspect of this book that reduced my enjoyment of it. I, therefore, rate it 5 out of 5 stars.

I would recommend it to anyone who is curious about human psychology, evolution, and why we believe what we believe. It is perfect for readers who are tired of surface-level debates about fake news and want to understand the deeper root cause. If you enjoy books that challenge your thinking, make you question your own assumptions, and are not afraid to be controversial in search of truth, you will find this book very rewarding.

Reviewed by Faith Ozioma September 24, 2026